How a busy executive turned excess cash into $36,000 of tax-free passive income — without doing any of the work.
Today we continue the series on the real estate investing journeys of real people.
Although I change their names and some of the personal specifics, these are real stories based on real people I know. They have generously given me permission to share their real estate investment experience.
In 5 Ways to Invest in Real Estate (From $60 to All-In), I introduced seven fictional investor types. Last week I wrote about someone following the path of Rockstar Reggie. Today I tell the story of Maria following the path of Hands Off Harry.
Rockstar Reggie: works as an employee of a real estate company and participates in the company’s property success after 5-10 years.
Hands Off Harry: invests as a limited partner.
As I did last week, I will follow a consistent format:
Investor background
Goal as a real estate investor
The first investment
Current portfolio
Wins and challenges
Advice for prospective investors
Professor Bateman’s observations
A HUGE thanks to the real Maria for letting me share her story!
Let’s dig in.
Investor Background
Maria is 42 years old as we start her story. She is well underway in a successful career. She has risen to an executive at a mid-sized company where she has worked for over 10 years. She enjoys the work and is well compensated.
She is married and has two children in elementary school. Her husband brings in some income, but she is the main earner and provides health insurance for the entire family via her employment.
She consistently contributes to her 401K and enjoys the partial match provided by her employer. Over her 15+ year career she has built up ample savings (it helped that her husband also used to be a high wage earner), some of which she has put into stock index funds and some of which she has held in cash.
Goal As A Real Estate Investor
As much as Maria enjoys her work and the associated income, she realizes her current income is 100% dependent on her employment. Her goal is to diversify her income by investing in cash flowing, tax-efficient real estate.
As she works full-time and is married with young children, she has limited time to focus on real estate investing. She is self-aware enough to recognize that the best path to achieve her goals of passive income is to invest as a limited partner (LP) with an experienced general partner (GP).
She has friends who have invested as LPs and have confirmed that the income is truly passive. Other than filling out the paperwork to make the investment with the GP (aka subscription documents), wiring in the money, and sending the annual tax documents (aka K-1 statement) to her tax accountant, there is no time commitment from her.
The First Investment
Through talking with people she knows who are LP investors, she identifies three potential GPs to invest with. She starts by reviewing everything on each of their websites. Here’s what she learns:
GP #1: invests in retail properties. Their stated goal is to maximize returns for their investors.
GP #2: very similar to GP #1.
GP #3: invests in apartment properties. Their stated goal is to provide tax-efficient quarterly distributions to their investors.
Through a little research, she learns that the term “maximize returns” means that the GP is focused on total profit for each deal. This means they often sell the properties when they can get a good price. This strategy does not meet her goals. She wants consistent distributions.
It is clear to Maria that the goal of GP #3 best aligns with Maria’s goals.
She gets introduced to the investor relations contact at GP #3 through her friend. Their conversation goes well and GP #3 starts sending Maria new deals to look at.
After looking at a couple of deals, Maria realizes she has a long way to go until she develops enough expertise to decide which deals to invest in.
She decides that GP #3 is the expert and she trusts their judgment. Her plan will be to invest consistently in their deals as opposed to making a big bet on a single one.
Based on this, she invests $20,000 in the first deal. It is projected to distribute a 6% annual cash-on-cash return: $20,000 x 6% = $1,200 per year or $300 per quarter. It will be 100% shielded from tax due to depreciation. The quarterly distributions are expected to grow to 9% by year 5 due to the GP’s value-add strategy. $20,000 x 9% =$1,800 or $450 per quarter.
The $300 per quarter won’t change her life, but she is happy she now has some income other than from her employer.
Current Portfolio - End of Year 5
Over the next 5 years, things go very well at her company. Her annual bonuses increase and she has more money to invest with GP #3.
During this 5 year period she invests an additional $520,000 in 11 more deals, bringing her total investment to $540,000 in 12 deals: $20,000 each in the first two and then $50,000 each in the next ten. Her distributions have grown to $9,000 per quarter. Here is the math: $540,000 x 6.67% annual distribution = $36,000 or $9,000 per quarter.
$9,000 per quarter after tax is starting to make a nice impact on her financial life.
Wins and Challenges
Win #1 – She Has Diversified Her Income
Although she could not live on $36,000 per year, she has been able to successfully diversify her income. This gives her comfort and makes her feel she is no longer 100% dependent on her employer for income.
Win #2 – Investing with a Capable and Trustworthy GP
GP #3 has done everything they said they would. The deals have generally performed as expected and GP #3 has demonstrated they have high integrity.
Challenge #1 – Extended Tax Returns
Before she was a real estate investor, her tax returns were very simple. She received a W-2 statement from her employer, a 1099 statement from Vanguard for her stock investments, and a 1098 statement related to her mortgage. Everything was delivered by the end of January and she was able to file her tax returns on time.
Now that she is a real estate investor, she receives a K-1 statement for each of her 12 investments. Some of them are delivered on time, but some don’t come until just before the April 15th filing deadline. This requires her to extend her tax filings to October 15th. Not only is this annoying, but she ends up having to pay her tax accountant more to complete the returns.
Challenge #2 – Refinances
The only thing that surprised Maria about the performance of the 12 properties and the GP’s approach is that the GP has an active refinance program. Once a deal starts cash flowing at around 7%+ per year, the GP completes a cash-out refinance.
10 of the properties have been refinanced, returning $135,000 to Maria.
Although it is nice to have the money to invest in new deals, it generally reduces the future distributions due to the higher amount of debt. She is finding it is unrealistic to think that any of these deals will ever hit the 9% projected stabilized cash-on-cash returns as the GP will do a cash-out refinance before they get there.
Advice for Prospective Investors
Maria has some advice for prospective real estate investors:
LP Investing Is Passive: busy life? No problem. LP investing is truly passive. The GP does all the work. She is fine paying them their fees and promote in exchange for them doing all the work.
Align Goals: make sure you understand the goals of the GP you are investing in. Investing with GP #1 or #2 would not have helped Maria achieve her goals.
No Control Over Liquidity: only invest money you don’t need to get back. These investments don’t have any liquidity as GP #3 focused on long-term cash flow with cash-out refinances every 5 years or so. Yes, the cash-out refinances produce some liquidity, but the GP is the one who decides the amount and timing of these proceeds.
Tax-Efficiency: depreciation shields the cash flow distributions from taxes.
Tax Return Delays: be ready to extend your tax returns to the October 15th filing deadline due to the time it takes to receive your K-1s. And you will pay your tax accountant more due to the increased complexity of your tax return.
Financial Independence Is Still Far Away: it will take investing a lot of money to replace her salary and bonus. The math to earn $100,000 in annual cash flow is $100,000 / 6% =$1,666,666.
Maria is happy with her progress as a real estate investor. She found a capable and trustworthy GP whose goals (mainly) align with her investing goals.
Professor Bateman’s Observations
Right GP: Maria found the right GP. This is critical if you follow the passive, LP investing route. If Maria had chosen one of the two GPs whose goal was to maximize returns, she would have had an entirely different outcome. Pro Tip: really take the time to find a GP whose goals match your own.
Accredited Investor: Maria has enough income from her employment to qualify as an accredited investor. Many GPs will only accept LPs if they are accredited investors. Pro Tip: there are multiple things that can qualify you to be an accredited investor. The two most common are (i) annual income over $200,000 individually or $300,000 combined with your spouse or (ii) a net worth over $1 million excluding the value of your primary residence.
Tax-Efficient Distributions: due to the high amount of income earned via her employment, Maria is likely paying a 33%+ total tax (she lives in California). The $36,000 in after-tax cash flow is the equivalent of $54,000 before tax if the money was earned through her employment. Here’s the math: $54,000 x 33.3% =$18,000 tax. $54,000 - $18,000 tax = $36,000 after tax.
Realistic Approach: Maria’s life is already very full. Being a passive LP investor is the best of alternatives for Maria. There is always the option to become a direct investor in the future.
Dollar Cost Averaging: Maria is making consistent investments in real estate over time as opposed to one big bet. This gives her diversification both in terms of (i) the different real estate and (ii) the market timing in which she invests. This diversification lowers the risk that she will be wiped out by a bad investment or poor market timing.
Slow Road to Financial Independence: she is a long-way from financial independence, but investing in cash flowing, tax efficient real estate is a great way to convert her excess cash into passive “forever” income.
Maria vs. Simon
Maria is following the path of Hands Off Harry. She has excess cash to invest but limited time. She has chosen to invest with a GP that buys large ($30+ million) projects in primary markets with low risk, focused on recurring cash flow.
Simon is following the path of Rockstar Reggie. He is able to invest in the deals his employer buys — focused on shorter-term (3-5 year) hold periods to maximize returns. This strategy is similar to GP #1 and #2.
Maria, in her 40’s, is on a path to build up passive cash flow. Simon, in his 30’s, is on a path to build up his net worth.
Different strategies and opportunities for different times in each of these investor’s lives.
As I share other stories, find the one that fits you best.